MTA to Get More State
Legislators Plan to Supersede Agency's Doomsday Budget
The artificial March 25 deadline set by the MTA
came and went Wednesday. The state legislature has still not reached agreement
on the transit agency’s demand for new state subsidies, and by what means the
necessary funds will be raised. The agency’s response was to enact what
it called a doomsday budget, with 25 to 30 per cent fare increases and
substantial service reductions. This is intended to shift blame from the
on previously free bridges to and from Manhattan
and for service cuts.
The agency's gambit is in part justified and in part
showmanship. They need money, so they create an immediate crisis in the hope
that someone will solve it for them. They also need to reduce their overhead in
a way that will minimize service reductions, while protecting their passengers
from the brunt of the cost. This is what private companies that are not
publicly subsidized do in hard times.
It is probable that sometime, but not until next week at the
earliest, that a package will be agreed upon by Albany
and the MTA
DIGRESSION: There is no specific location that evokes the MTA
in the way the Pentagon, the White House, Albany
and City Hall serve as inanimate symbols of agencies or official bodies.
We would nominate 2 Broadway, the site of their costliest folly, where hundreds
of millions of dollars were poured into the renovation of a building they do
not own. This provided luxury office space with dramatic harbor views for
back-room operations by employees who could have been housed in Long
small fraction of what the MTA
A numbered building, however, lacks the panache and prestige
that such a huge agency deserves. It is also a symbol of corruption and
dysfunctionality. Going the other way, Grand Central is much too noble a
name, while Madison Avenue (where they now occupy an office building at No.
341, across the street from Brooks Brothers) is an address associated with
advertising, just as Wall Street means finance.
Penn Station clearly evokes transit, but it is owned by
Amtrak, a country-wide railroad operation. Amtrak could be thought of as
similar to a GSE
enterprise, which would put it up there with the losers, Fannie and Freddie,
whose irresponsible lending practices were a major contribution to our present
Another possibility is Fulton
which will now receive federal stimulus funds for the second billion of a
facelift for a long corridor, with minimal, if any, service improvement.
This was built because the unions, potential contractors and idle MTA
engineers all wanted it. Former MTA
chair Peter Kalikow made it his personal mission.
Rockefeller built Albany
he was derided for an “edifice complex,” but the buildings were at least
useful. Nelson’s towers were the Albany anchor to his brother David’s One
Chase Manhattan Plaza, built in the late 1950’s – an attractive modern
building that was intended to create an architectural renaissance downtown.
Although the Chase Plaza
does not work all that well, the structure is a great addition to the landscape
(or skyscape). Fulton Street has gravitas because of Robert Fulton, inventor of the steamboat, a valuable mode
of water transportation in the 19th century. Originally derided as Fulton
Folly, the steamboat proved its worth. It also linked New
both important cities for the MTA
Currently, to reach Albany
by rail you must use Amtrak; the MTA
line only goes as far north as Poughkeepsie
for which DutchessCounty
residents pay an additional quarter of one per cent sales tax, like the
downstate counties. END DIGRESSION
Those of us who oppose bridge tolls have the responsibility
of suggesting alternative revenue sources for mass transit. One idea is
to increase the gasoline tax, either for the MTA
counties, or state-wide, with the upstate revenues going to local transit
systems. The problem is that gasoline is already relatively heavily taxed
in New York State
There is a state excise tax of 8 cents per gallon, a state sales tax of 4 per
cent (capped at 8 cents), a petroleum business tax of 16.6 cpg, an oil spill
fund is 0.196 cpg, a fuel quality testing fee of 0.5 cpg, county sales taxes
(averaging 7.9 cpg). The federal gas tax amounts to 18.63 cpg, including
the underground storage tax and a superfund tax.
New York State
rates are the reason that gas costs about 25 cents less in New
Another suggestion is to increase auto registration fees
more sharply for heavier motor vehicles. An SUV would then pay
substantially more than a Prius. This was the case many years ago, when
the weight of the car was required to be listed on the registration document,
and the fee was directly proportional to the weight. Now we have relatively minor
increases until the vehicle’s weight exceeds 7000 pounds, at which time the
tax jumps to $112 per two years. SUVs (sport utility vehicles)
weigh between 4400 (Ford Explorer) and 5500 pounds (Chevy Tahoe), so neither is
affected by the substantially higher tax rate above 7k. However, Governor
Paterson’s proposed budget already provides a 25 per cent increase in licensing
and registration fees.
The burdens imposed by increased taxation lead to
consideration of cost reduction by the MTA
as their contribution to balancing the budget.
Cost reduction can be accomplished either by discontinuing
services, freezing or lowering personnel costs, or by requiring employees to
perform more work. Any of these proposals will be opposed by public
employee unions, who are the largest contributors to legislators’ campaigns,
and whose lobbying expenses are the highest in Albany
The affinity between politicians and labor unions has
developed over the years. It is relatively non-partisan, and when the
Republicans controlled the State Senate the unions contributed to their
campaigns. The Working Families Party, small but militant, is ardently
pro-labor and can take part in Democratic primary contests, thus instilling
fear in timid legislators who are accustomed to following the directions
of their leaders. In the 2008 Democratic primary on the Lower East Side,
the WFP endorsed Speaker Sheldon Silver for re-nomination, a reasonable
decision in view of the likelihood of his victory (He won handily.), and his
support for their issues.
One question as yet unanswered will be whether Governor
Paterson will ask Senate Republicans for help in imposing bridge tolls,
bypassing his own party members.
A related issue is whether the Senate Republicans will allow
themselves to be used for this purpose, and, if they do, what price they will
exact from Paterson and Speaker Silver. Since all negotiations are
conducted in secret (as I suppose is necessary when people get serious), we
have no idea at this time what the outcome will be.
It would be foolish for the Republicans to allow themselves
to be bought, but the Congressional GOP went along with President Bush’s
ever-increasing budgets as long as they were larded with earmarks for their
districts. Why should New York State Republicans be more principled than
counterparts? Maybe because they really want to win in 2010 in a wave of
revulsion against high taxes (which will be adopted). They would not look
idealistic if they collaborated to tax bridges that have been free for a
century. But never underestimate the hunger of a tribe, now reduced to 30 souls
and deprived of the majority they enjoyed and exploited while Senate Democrats
spent 43 years in the wilderness, longer than it took to cross Sinai.
It is also possible that the governor will lean on his
colleague, Malcolm Smith, with sufficient force to persuade Smith to recant his
heresy in opposing bridge tolls. Smith’s hold on the majority leadership is not
the strongest. It relies on the likelihood that since every other Senator
wants to be the leader himself or herself, none of them can find sufficient
support for a coup.
This afternoon Speaker Silver and leader Smith announced that the legislature would aim to resolve the
transit budget issue by Wednesday, April 1. Transit would be considered
at the same time but not as part of the adoption of the State budget, which by
law must be approved by 12.01 a.m. on
April 1. Last year, the legislature was a day late and billions of
Silver said each body would consider various issues in their
party conferences. The powerful Silver, who has been Speaker since
February 1994, enjoys a 109-41 majority in the Assembly, while Smith has the
bare minimum of 32-30. A quorum of the Senate, a necessity if taxes are
to be increased, is said to be 38 members, which provides the Republicans with
a way to block action if they chose to use it. That course might not,
however, be politically desirable. The Federal governmental showdown of
1995 was widely blamed on Republican speaker Newt Gingrich, and led to the loss
of Congressional seats by the GOP.
We will see whether or not the issue can be resolved by
Budget Day. And watch out for other legislation which is likely to be sneaked
in during the closing rush. Of particular concern is a bill sponsored by trial
lawyers which would double their fees in major cases.
Enjoy the weekend.