Documents Show Ratner and NY State Provide No Guarantees for Atlantic Yards Affordable Housing

eHezi Archives 7 Comments

Ratner_Bruce Brooklyn, NY —  Journalist Norman Oder, on his Atlantic Yards Report, shows today that there are no guarantees that developer Forest City Ratner will build the 2,250 units of affordable housing promised for the Atlantic Yards development proposal in Prospect Heights, Brooklyn. There are no guarantees that the developer will build any affordable units at all.

Based on documents obtained by Freedom of Information Law requests, Oder makes it clear that Ratner is only required to seek funding through subsidies for affordable housing. The documents reveal that if the developer is unable to get the funds he wants he doesn't have to build the number of units he's promised. Ratner is not required to get the funds and there is no understanding by the Empire State Development Corporation whether there will be room for all of those units under the annual allotments of housing bonds for New York City and State.

The General Project Plan, which is the proposal's governing document approved in 2006, originally had provisions that nearly guaranteed Atlantic Yards affordable housing. But those provisions never made it into the final version. The Modified General Project Plan (MGPP) released in late June also does not include those provisions guaranteeing affordable housing. 

The public comment period on the MGPP ends on August 31st and, presumably without those guarantees, the Empire State Development Corporation is expected to rubberstamp the MGPP on September 17.

"We've expected all along that Forest City Ratner and New York State have no documented guarantees that Atlantic Yards will include 2,250 affordable housing units. Now the evidence shows it is true: there are no affordable housing guarantees for Atlantic Yards," said Develop Don't Destroy Brooklyn spokesman Daniel Goldstein. "There should be a political firestorm over this from all of the elected officials, including Mayor Bloomberg, who've supported Atlantic Yards for the affordable housing, but we won't hold our breath on that." 

The Atlantic Yards Report article, "Documents show affordable housing guarantees considered but discarded; no apparent effort to ascertain if housing bonds were sufficient," is at:

It may behoove Yonkers to review the contracts that are pending to ascertain if those contracts are iron clad. 
eHeziDocuments Show Ratner and NY State Provide No Guarantees for Atlantic Yards Affordable Housing

Comments 7

  1. most of the affordable housing commitmments are written on toilet paper. They promise it up front then, like Capelli is already doing in White Plains, dont build it. Its part of the dog & pony show…I think it’s the Pony

  2. 4:57 Yonkers can’t sell the”affordable” units it already built.Get government out of housing construction,it doesn’t know or care about costs,markets or management.

  3. no its the smae promise SFC told Yonkers to get their foot in the door, they will back out on this too, like FCR. Amicone will let any developer do anything they wish…even hijack the city.

  4. no affordable units means that the prices
    of the condo’s built will retain their
    value….and in fact if you read the housing
    settlement yonkers is not one of the municipalities bound by the settlement and
    required to build any more units than
    it already has

Leave a Reply

This comment will be displayed anonymously. Your name and email address will not be published.

Comments that are off topic will be removed. If you want a topic to be covered, email me at:

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.