Yonkers Police Officer Wayne Simoes’ Legal Counsel in Federal Civil Suit v Ms. Irma Marquez Arrive at $1.25 Million Settlement Before Honorable Cathy Seibel
HEZI ARIS

eHezi Community, Governance, History, Law, People, Politics, Westchester County, NY, White Plains, NY, Yonkers, NY 26 Comments

Scale of Justice

Breaking News Exclusive

Update as of July 19, 2017@ 7:30pm

 

WHITE PLAINS, NY and YONKERS, NY — July 17, 2017 — The Federal Civil Rights lawsuit filed against the City of Yonkers and Yonkers Police Officer Wayne Simoes was settled on July 10, 2017. While the Federal Criminal Case exonerated P.O. Simoes of wrongdoing with respect to Ms. Irma Marquez, a home health aide at the time of the March 3, 2007 incident.

Ms. Marquez was recognized and witnessed by way of surveillance video footage to have suffered a concussion, a fractured jaw, both eyes black and blue, facial lacerations, bruises, swelling of her neck, torso among other parts of her body. The video recording tape, reviewed by then Westchester County District Attorney Janet DiFiore’s Office, revealed that P.O. Simoes lifted Ms. Marquez off her feet, driving her face onto the ceramic tile floor of La Fonda Restaurant, located at 57 Palisade Avenue, Yonkers, New York. P.O. Simoes thereafter handcuffed and charged the unconscious and seriously injured woman with Obstruction of Governmental Administration and arrested her. The catalyst that fomented this conduct was initiated when Ms. Marquez leaned over to get a better perspective of the medical assistance being provided to her niece who was earlier rendered unconscious when struck by another unapprehended assailant. It was on May 9, 2008 that a jury acquitted Ms. Marquez of all charges.

“If anyone other than a police officer was caught on tape doing what Officer Symoes did to Irma Marquez they would have rightfully been arrested and prosecuted,” said Gary T. Certain, Esq., of Certain & Zilberg, PLLC, attorneys for Ms. Marquez.  Mr. Certain, who represented  Irma Marquez in the criminal case, and filed the Federal lawsuit in the Southern District of New York, added, “This case suggests that Janet DiFiore’s Office may not be capable of honestly prosecuting egregious police misconduct.”

Certain & Zilberg, PLLC continued to represent Ms. Marquez in the Federal Civil Suit that followed and was argued in the Federal Courtroom of Hon. Cathy Seibel.

The City of Yonkers was represented by Wilson Elser, and Wayne Simoes was represented by the Quinn Law Firm, legal counsel for the PBA.

Yonkers Corporation Counsel Michael V. Curti, Esq. advised: “Following mediation sessions with a federal magistrate judge, a settlement in principle has been reached. While the plaintiff has approved the settlement, the City’s governing body must now consider it. I cannot comment upon the amount of the settlement until a resolution is presented to the City Council for consideration, which will likely be in early August.”

Gary Certain, Esq., on behalf of Certain & Zilberg, PLLC, by email advised: “We are pleased to have been able to reach a resolution that brings some measure of closure to Ms. Marquez. It is our hope that this settlement, along with the City of Yonkers’ recent settlement with the U.S. Department of Justice will pressure the Yonkers Police Department to treat members of the public with appropriate dignity and respect.”

Yonkers Tribune sources advise the settlement agreement between the three sides, e.g. Wilson Elser, on behalf of the City of Yonkers, The Quinn Law Firm on behalf of P.O. Wayne Simoes, and Certain & Zilberg, PLLC, on behalf or Irma Marquez was agreed upon to the tune of $1.25million in favor of Ms. Irma Marquez.

 

Updated Addendum – July 19, 2017 – 7:30pm

It was only after Wayne Simoes was exonerated from criminal wrong doing that the City of Yonkers (CoY) decided to take on the defense of Simoes with respect to the Federal Civil lawsuit. The Quinn Law Firm is alleged to have spent its own funds to defend Simoes in the first case, the Federal Criminal Lawsuit. The amount of money spent by the Yonkers Police Benevolent Association has never been divulged and has yet to be divulged or even audited. What is known is that then PBA President Eddie Armour and then PBA V-P Keith Olson cajoled The Quinn Law Firm to take on the Simoes case while funds were to be collected for Simoes’ defense. To that end, and with the knowledge that a defense would be expensive, the PBA membership had been asked to chip in a donation of $100 per person to cover the expected legal fees expected. While over $40,000 in cash was said to have been collected, only a few thousand dollars were given to Simoes, yet no accounting of the alleged missing money has ever been divulged. When a Yonkers DPW worker was caught by a surveillance camera overlooking PBA V-P Keith Olson’s desk, from which $300 was allegedly taken, did V-P Olson suggest that the money “stolen” from his desk was part of the money collected for Simoes’ benefit.

From the time the initial criminal charges were dismissed to the civil suit moving forward, Yonkers City Hall deemed it appropriate to exonerate and indemnify Simoes from the legal burden. Over some time Simoes was elevated to Yonkers Police Sergeant. Simoes’ new rank in the Yonkers Police Department caused his union representation to move from the Yonkers PBA to the Yonkers Captains’ Lieutenants, Sergeants Association (CLSA). The Quinn Law Firm had then represented both unions.

Yonkers City Hall had decided to engage the services of the very well respected and expensive law firm of Wilson, Elser on behalf of Simoes. WIlson, Elser bill by the hour. The services they have rendered on behalf of Simoes over the decade they have been involved in this case have not been divulged.

§ C12-11 Civil Action Against Police Officers and Police Supervisors; Defense and Indemnification review panel.
[Added 7-13-1989 by L.L. No. 12-1989; 11-4-2008 by L.L. No. 10-2008]

A. 
The City of Yonkers shall provide for the defense of any civil action or proceeding brought against a duly appointed police officer of the City of Yonkers and shall indemnify and save harmless such police officer from any judgment of a court of competent jurisdiction whenever such action, proceeding or judgment is for punitive or exemplary damages arising out of a negligent act or other tort of such police officer committed while in the proper discharge of his/her duties and within the scope of his/her employment.

B.
The determination of whether any such police officer properly discharged his/her duties within the scope of his/her employment shall be made by a majority vote of a three-member panel. The panel shall consist of the police commissioner, the corporation counsel or his/her designee and the Mayor or his/her designee.

At issue for CoY is who are the three so designated persons that had to have voted in the above mentioned three-member panel, what was their vote, what the final vote was, and who voted in the majority?

The most relevant concern for Yonkersites is how much will these known and not known costs add up to burden the taxpayers?

eHeziYonkers Police Officer Wayne Simoes’ Legal Counsel in Federal Civil Suit v Ms. Irma Marquez Arrive at $1.25 Million Settlement Before Honorable Cathy Seibel
HEZI ARIS

Comments 26

  1. Don’t know how many people jump out a widow backwards? Said the lawyer to the jury. Why was the death certificate changed? Said the lawyers to Medical Examiner. Case closed $42 million sounds about right. Lol can’t wait.

  2. Love how Yonkers always under the cover of the summer sneaks these extra taxes on the public. If no wrong was done then why is Yonkers paying up? Please tell.

  3. There is no way that this can be sustained.
    Everyone in Yonkers knows how brutal the YPD is.
    No warrants and then the great Alley Ooop !
    With No Net.
    Make sure you live on the lobby floor in Yonkers.
    Body Slamming a woman, No Warrant Entry, and then a Alley Ooop !
    BULLYING and INTIMIDATION.
    LYING and DECEITS
    PLEASE UNCLE SAM HELP

  4. While the video clip makes PO Simoes look bad, the “small” woman clearly was fighting with him, and there are onlookers who aren’t seen. Had the cops gotten into a melee with the woman and the other guests, the videotape would have looked just as bad; and probably accompanied by multiple claims of police brutality and injuries.
    The fact is that the whole incident could have been avoided if the woman had listened to the police and stepped back. Too often, members of the public act like compliance with a police officer’s directive is optional, then complain when they learn it is not.
    None of the other guests stepped up to stop the woman from fighting with the cops, and her behavior was escalating. P.O. Simoes took quick and decisive action that effectively ended the threat, and the City should have supported and indemnified him in the first place instead of hanging him out to dry.

    1. Sounds like police speak to me-if he did nothing wrong the COY would not have paid-they avoid a civil trial and more damaging evidence coming to light.taxpayers COY out $1.25 million.Taxed out

  5. The Spano’s are crying wolf about Barry, but turn a blind eye to what goes on in the Spanopolice department where nothing is on the level. The city better get another few million together for the Tenor case.

    1. Quinn gets $125,000 plus from PBA. Olson’s gets first shot and use of Quinn before all other members even though they have been paying for years.

  6. So he was aquitted in court, it was proven the videotape was altered, so basically he did nothing wrong. Yet, the city still pays this person $1.25M. While it may have been more expensive to continue this fight in court the fact remains that this suit should have been dismissed right at the get go. She caused her own injuries yet her and her lawyer get compensated dearly, and the taxpayer pays.

    1. Nothing wrong, ‘Taxpayer’?? Do you remember that incident?? I don’t care if that tape of the incident was accelerated or slowed down – slamming someone to the floor is slamming someone to the floor, period. She was a tiny woman. I don’t care what she did it was not physically threatening. He threw her down like a rag doll. In basketball terms, a slam-dunk. Very handily lifted her in the air and threw her down, like a rag doll. Apparently, thankfully, he did NOT get away with it after all. I only hope the City of Yonkers is not on the hook for this, too.

      1. If he slammed her to the ground then there would have been a conviction. The feds don’t fool around. Were you there to witness her being thrown to the ground? I know I wasn’t so I would have to rely on what happened in court, and the decision of those citizens who served on the jury. If they thought he was wrong his a$$ would have been in jail.

        So I still believe she’s a ghetto lotto player.

        1. Not testifying to her character or lack thereof. Merely saying a small woman, extremely drunk as per the testimony, is no match for the let’s say about 7 cops who were there. Don’t you think that among them they could have handled this better? And are you so stupid that you think that juries always get it right? Moron.

      2. To be fair, Wayne is a tiny man. He DID get away with it & has since been promoted. HE’S not paying $1.25 million, you are.

        1. I KNOW he’s a tiny man. Gone are the days of the tough tall cops. Now that they have allowed women on the force they had to lower the height standards for men. I wonder how many of these tiny cops use steroids to compensate. I saw one cop years ago that I could fit in my pocket.

  7. Will the Yonkers PBA President ever find Wayne’s missing cash and turn it over, or give it back to the membership? Oh that’s right there are no accounting records for cash fundraising.

  8. This case was “settled” just a couple of days after the Controller “certified” the budget? Was this pending settlement liability disclosed to the Controller? Where is the money in the budget to pay for this?

Leave a Reply

This comment will be displayed anonymously. Your name and email address will not be published.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.