Saving Jacob’s Sheep

Jonathan Feldstein Charity, Community, Culture, Finance, Governance, History, Israel Leave a Comment

Columnist Jonathan Feldstein

EFRAT, ISRAEL — September 13, 2020 — Jenna Lewinsky is panicked, rightly so. Shes facing eviction.  But its not a bank that is forcing her to give up her home.  Shes not done anything wrong.  In fact, shes done everything right.  Many people have helped her to get where she is.  Jennas problem is unique.

Jenna is panicked because all her years of devotion to bring home and preserve a biblical species of sheep to the Judean mountains south of Jerusalem risks being pulled out from under her.  Its not just about her physical efforts, or (emotional) commitment and devotion.  Her passion is driven biblically, and symbolic of so many things even bigger than she is.

Jenna Lewinsky with newly born lamb.

Jacobs Sheep are a distinct species mentioned in the Bible (Genesis 30). Jenna discovered the sheep in Canada.  She investigated how they had been dispersed from the Land of Israel during the biblical exile of the Jewish people, and had become cherished around the world for their uniqueness; spotted and speckled just as in the Bible, with some having as many as five and six horns. Jenna worked tirelessly to overcome bureaucratic challenges and raise the funds to bring them home for the first time in thousands of years.  She succeeded, and has been breeding them in the Land of the patriarchs and matriarchs, giving the lambs biblical names to connect them with the people to whom God promised Land. Today in Israel they are considered an endangered species.  Her flock is the only one in Israel.

The threats facing Jenna are not from enemies. They are not because of a pandemic. The threats are from the army.  The Israeli army.  Jenna is appealing the eviction notice she received, not just on principle, but because she was given only four days to leave, or risk everything shes worked to build being bulldozed.  Even without the sheep, packing and finding a place to live could well take more than four days, especially with one of those being Shabbat, the day of rest when all work is suspended.  But moving the sheep requires extra steps to transport them, space to house and care for them, and permits.

Eviction often carries the stigma of doing something wrong.  Jenna is not being evicted because of that.  Simply, the army says that in order to remain where she is, she needs to provide security for herself and her baby which she has not yet done.  Indeed, the army is looking out for her, and being practical.  Perhaps its not reasonable for the army to provide resources 24/7 to protect her individually when it has a job to protect a whole country. Or maybe, its a matter of priorities and allocation of resources.

Either way, because much of her support and financial recourses come from tourists, and tourism is non-existent now, as a single mother she does not have the resources to provide he security that she needs.

Bureaucracy has also gotten in the way because the very community leaders that put Jenna and the sheep on the isolated mountaintop overlooking Bethlehem, and who praised, celebrated, took credit for, and even raised money to support her, have (as of this writing) not stepped up to help prevent, or at least put off, her eviction.

In addition to being responsible for relocating a flock of biblical sheep, and her infant son, Jenna is feeling let down by the people who placed her there.  Hers is not just a biblical story, the literal return of lost sheep, but a modern Zionist story.  Indeed, the land that she was given on which to set up her farm is slated to become part of a large neighborhood thats part of Efrat, a community of some 11,000 residents.  Jennas leaving, she says, will make the mountaintop not just empty again, but will effectively cede the land upon which Efrat is zoned to build a neighborhood that will have it potentially 20,000 additional residents. Thats anti-Zionist.  

Does Jenna feel cheated, like the patriarch Jacob did with Laban, his father in law?  No.  Im thankful for the concern for our safety. But thats never been my motivation.  Shes been selfless in her mission, living without running water or electricity. Its not as if shes looking for something for herself.  She notes that even in the pandemic, Ive taken no government funds. Rather than asking for a handout, Im able bodied and have two hands and can work.

Nevertheless, now, she cant help but wonder if she and her sheep are simply caught in the crosshairs of something bigger that would have Israel scale back building in Jewish communities in Biblical Judea and Samaria in order to placate Arab nations and neighbors toward peace agreements.   She wonders if shes become expendable because there is no tourism to Israel now, so the people who facilitated her being on the abandoned mountaintop don’t see a (short term) benefit in her being there by attracting tourists who once came to visit and volunteer.

Jenna believes that once she is gone, Palestinian Arab shepherds and others who have intruded, makingtheir presence well known to intimidate if not threaten me outright, will practically be able to take over the evacuated land.  Her presence there, she says, prevents that.

In her mind, thats not good for her or the sheep, and certainly not good for Israel.  The peace agreement with the UAE changed the paradigm of land for peace to peace for peace.  But she wonders if thats true, and wonders if local leaders who facilitated her being where she is have not ceded the land in their minds, if not officially.

Jenna would like to stay where she is, with her sheep in the Judean mountains where they belong. But providing security alone is nearly an additional $5000 per month.  She is appealing to anyone who will listen and can help, at least to give her a reasonable period of time to relocate, given the expense and bureaucracy of doing so.

If youd like to help Jenna and to protect and preserve Jacobs Sheep, please click here to donate and share with others to do so, or for other information and updates please email

Jonathan FeldsteinSaving Jacob’s Sheep

Leave a Reply

This comment will be displayed anonymously. Your name and email address will not be published.

Comments that are off topic will be removed. If you want a topic to be covered, email me at:

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.