Will Islam Survive Islamism?
By Daniel Pipes

Tribune Archives, Community, Governance, History, House of Worship, International, Islam, People 1 Comment

More Muslims Fear and Reject a Radical Version of Islam

Washington Times illustration of non-Islamism by Linas Garsys.

Daniel Pipes received his A.B. (1971) and Ph.D. (1978) from Harvard University, both in history, and spent six years studying abroad, including three years in Egypt. Mr. Pipes speaks French, and reads Arabic and German. He is the president of the Middle East Forum and his bi-weekly column appears regularly in the Washington Times and in newspapers around the globe, including the Israel Hayom (Israel), La Razón (Spain), Liberal (Italy), National Post (Canada), and the Australian.

YONKERS, NY — November 16, 2021 — Islamist movement, which seeks to apply medieval Islamic laws and build a worldwide caliphate, has expanded massively in the past half-century. But it now faces a significant and growing counter-movement, especially in Muslim-majority countries. Growing numbers of Muslims, spurred by shocks like the fall of Kabul, fear and reject this radical version of Islam. Awareness of the anti-Islamist surge has been largely limited to those directly involved but it deserves to be much better known.

Anti-Islamism comprises four complementary trends. Going from quietest to most radical, they are: moderate Islam, irreligiosity, apostasy, and conversion to other religions. All have an international presence but, for illustrative purposes, I shall focus in each case on a key Middle Eastern country: moderate Islam in Egypt, irreligiosity in Turkey, atheism in Saudi Arabia, and conversion in Iran.

Moderation: Husni Mubarak’s 30-year police state so consistently accommodated Islamists that Egyptians dared not oppose them. His fall from power in 2011 finally permitted an open expression of views, which the one-year Islamist rule of Mohamed Morsi further galvanized. The results have been hyperbolically anti-Islamist, as seen by street attacks on Muslim Brotherhood-appearing men, by women discarding the hijab, and the immense popularity of scathingly anti-Islamist figures such as Islam al-Behairy, Ibrahim Issa, Mukhtar Jom’ah, Khaled Montaser, and Abdallah Nasr. Even President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi, a former Islamist sympathizer, has accommodated these moderate sentiments.

Egyptian intellectual Ibrahim Issa.

Irreligiosity: Turkey’s Islamist president, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, has dominated the country’s politics since 2002 with the goal of raising a “pious generation.” But younger Turks are adopting non-Islamic ways. Survey research by Volkan Ertit found the sacred having less influence regarding such matters as belief in supernatural beings, clothing that reveals body shape, premarital flirtation, non-marital sex, and homosexuality. A government report documented the appeal of deism among religious school students. A 2012 WIN/Gallup survey found that “Not religious” persons make up 73 percent of Turkey’s population (the highest of 57 countries surveyed).

Apostasy: In Saudi Arabia, flat-out rejection of Islam “is spreading like wildfire” says a Saudi refugee. The WIN/Gallup survey found that “convinced atheists” make up 5 percent of the population in Saudi Arabia, the same as in the United States. The monarchy has responded in two ways. First, Crown Prince Mohammad bin Salman partially acquiesced to such sentiments by opening the country to many modern ways. Second, he promulgated anti-terrorist regulations that punish “calling for atheist thought in any form, or calling into question the fundamentals of the Islamic religion on which this country is based.” Yes, the monarchy fights atheism with anti-terrorist regulations.

Conversion: Shay Khatiri, an analyst, writes about Iran that “Islam is the fastest shrinking religion…, while Christianity is growing the fastest.” The Christian Broadcast Network goes further, asserting that “Christianity is growing faster in the Islamic Republic of Iran than in any other country in the world.” David Yeghnazar of Elam Ministries finds that “Iranians have become the most open people to the gospel.” According to a former Muslim, now an Evangelical priest, “We find ourselves facing what is more than a conversion to the Christian faith,” he said. “It’s a mass exodus from Islam.” Lela Gilbert and Arielle Del Turco report that the mullahs consider Christianity “an existential threat” to their rule. Reza Safa predicts Iran will become the first Muslim-majority country to convert to Christianity. Confirming these trends, the Iranian intelligence minister, Mahmoud Alavi, publicly expressed fears about Muslims converting to Christianity.

Iranian Intelligence Minister Mahmoud Alavi.

Some observations about this anti-Islamist surge:

It appears limited to Muslim-majority countries; among Muslims minorities, especially in the West, Islamism continues to grow.

Conspiracy theories to the contrary, it results almost entirely from internal developments among Muslims; non-Muslim have but a limited supporting role. As ever, Muslims determine their own destiny.

Anti-Islamists almost diametrically oppose Islamists on matters of faith, family, social relations, politics, and beyond. Among other implications, free-thinkers and ex-Muslims tend to be intensely pro-West, pro-America, and pro-Israel.

Expect to see anti-Islamist surges to appear in Nigeria, Bangladesh, and Indonesia, for Islamic trends historically begin in the Middle East and migrate outwards.

Thus does Islamism inadvertently drive Muslims away from Islam and potentially shake the very foundations of the faith. One Christian broadcaster even maintains that “the hold of Islam on the Muslim people has crumbled.” Radical utopianism has pushed the world’s second largest religious community into a concealed but severe crisis with volatile results.

Mr. Pipes (DanielPipes.org, @DanielPipes) is president of the Middle East Forum. © 2021 by Daniel Pipes. All rights reserved.

# # #


Original publication by the  Washington Times  on November 15, 2021



# # # # #

Mr. Pipes (DanielPipes.org, @DanielPipes) is president of the Middle East Forum. © 2021 by Daniel Pipes. All rights reserved.

TribuneWill Islam Survive Islamism?
By Daniel Pipes

Comments 1

  1. We’ve learned absolutely nothing since Jimmy Carter’s removal of the “Shah of Iran” as it replayed with dopey George W’s removal of Saddam Hussein as well as the removal of dictators in Egypt, Libya, Afghanistan and our coup attempts in Syria. You simply don’t remove secular dictators in the Middle East because they keep all of the warring religious factions in check and generally protect their Christians and in the case of Syria even their Jews. If the tensions rise in the region just get out of their way and let Israel assist the Sunni states deal with our nuclear Shiite threat with Iran as the Iranians deal with our Sunni state threat of ISIS and al Qaeda terrorism threats. In other words just let these 7th century Islamist retrogrades kill each other.

Leave a Reply

This comment will be displayed anonymously. Your name and email address will not be published.

Comments that are off topic will be removed. If you want a topic to be covered, email me at: ehezi@hush.com

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.