Tech Industry Asks Court to Block Texas Law that Targets Social Media Companies
By Amy Howe

Tribune Amy Howe, Governance, Law, People, SCOTUS Leave a Comment

Amy L Howe … Until September 2016, Amy served as the editor and reporter for SCOTUSblog, a blog devoted to coverage of the Supreme Court of the United States; she continues to serve as an independent contractor and reporter for SCOTUSblog. Before turning to full-time blogging, she served as counsel in over two dozen merits cases at the Supreme Court and argued two cases there. From 2004 until 2011, she co-taught Supreme Court litigation at Stanford Law School; from 2005 until 2013, she co-taught a similar class at Harvard Law School. She has also served as an adjunct professor at American University’s Washington College of Law and Vanderbilt Law School. Amy is a graduate of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and holds a master’s degree in Arab Studies and a law degree from Georgetown University.

WASHINGTON, D.C. — May 15, 2022 — Two technology trade groups came to the Supreme Court on Friday night, asking the justices to block a controversial Texas law that bars large social media platforms like Facebook and Twitter from moderating speech based on the viewpoints of their users. Describing the law as an “undisguised effort to level the speech playing field and control ‘Big Tech,’” the groups urged the court to reinstate a decision by a federal district judge in Texas that barred the state from enforcing the law.

Texas Gov. Greg Abbott signed the law, known as H.B. 20, last September, and it was slated to go into effect on Dec. 2, 2021. But the two trade groups, NetChoice and the Computer and Communications Industry Association, went to federal court in Texas, where U.S. District Judge Robert Pittman on Dec. 1 issued an order prohibiting the state from implementing the law.

On Wednesday, a divided panel of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 5th Circuit issued a one-sentence order in which it lifted Pittman’s injunction, clearing the way for the state to enforce the law.

Represented by two former Texas solicitors general, Scott Keller and Kyle Hawkins, as well as Paul Clement, who served as the U.S. solicitor general during the George W. Bush administration, the trade groups told the justicesthat H.B. 20 violates “bedrock First Amendment principles established by” the Supreme Court, which has “repeatedly recognized that private entities” – including websites – “have the right under the First Amendment to determine whether and how to disseminate speech.” Indeed, they suggested, “the entire impetus” for the law “was that Texas did not like how platforms were exercising” their editorial discretion “to remove or refrain from disseminating certain speech.” In his official signing statement, the groups noted, Abbott specifically stressed that it “is now law that conservative viewpoints in Texas cannot be banned on social media.”

Allowing the law to go into effect, the groups contended, will impose substantial costs on social media companies, requiring them to revamp how they operate. Moreover, they added, the companies will lose money, as advertisers will pull their ads rather than have them appear “next to vile, objectionable expression” such as Russian propaganda or Holocaust deniers, which the platforms will be obligated to permit under the law.

The groups also cited the cursory nature of the 5th Circuit’s order reinstating the law as another reason to put the order on hold while their challenge, as well as a challenge to a similar law in Florida, plays out. “Whether or not this Court ultimately agrees or disagrees,” the groups concluded, “Texas should not be allowed to transform the Internet before a single judge explains why Texas’s effort complies with the First Amendment.”

Justice Samuel Alito on Saturday morning directed Texas to file its response to the groups’ request by 5 p.m. on Wednesday, May 18.

This article was originally published at Howe on the Court on May 14, 2022.

TribuneTech Industry Asks Court to Block Texas Law that Targets Social Media Companies
By Amy Howe

Leave a Reply

This comment will be displayed anonymously. Your name and email address will not be published.

Comments that are off topic will be removed. If you want a topic to be covered, email me at:

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.